/* Tracker -------------------------------------------------- */
Showing posts with label Open Plan Layouts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Open Plan Layouts. Show all posts

6.2 Poorly Laid Out Teaching Plaza

The arrangement illustrated above is essentially four standard classrooms with the walls removed. This layout falls short in providing either the beneficial diversity of open plan teaching, or many of the educational benefits of open plan learning. This layout also has many acoustic limitations, as detailed below.

1 – Part of the corridor wall has been removed so students in the open plan space may be disturbed by movement in the corridor. Removing the corridor wall has no educational or design benefit and is therefore not recommended. A full height glazed partition would provide a visual connectivity, whilst providing adequate acoustic separation.

2 –The matrix of desks encourages non educational, disruptive communication to take place between tables, see section 6.6 for further details. With this table layout, teachers will need to project their voices to be heard by students at the back of the learning zone. Both of these factors will noticeably increase noise levels in this space, which will limit the performance, flexibility and overall user satisfaction of the space.

3 – Placing two dictatorial teaching spaces adjacent to each over will result in considerable levels of cross talk between teaching zones. Pupils will tend to be distracted by adjacent teaching activities. It is not recommended that dictatorial teaching spaces be placed adjacent to each other.

4 – The above plaza does not contain screens of any form, which results in an acoustically open space. Bookshelves, glazed screens, room corners and other elements could have been used to provide acoustic breaks. Failing to add screens will result in the propagation of the spoken voice and excessive noise spill from one zone to another. Both of these factors result in acoustic problems.

5 - The above space does not contain cellular areas for specifically noisy or quiet activities. This limits the potential educational diversity of this plaza. Open plan spaces are not normally suitable for either exclusively quiet learning or noisy activities, such as drama and multi media. It is therefore advised that a degree of cellular spaces are provided. The above plaza does not take specific measures to accommodate the acoustics of open plan teaching; hence the acoustic performance of this space is likely to be problematic. This conventional layout seems to be driven by the ease of converting back to an old, uninspiring four classroom layout. In summary, it is felt that a more inspiring functional space could be provided.

6.3 Well Laid Out Teaching Plaza

The teaching plaza illustrated above moves away from the conventional Victorian classroom layout. The result is a colourful, personal space, providing a wide range of education zones and resources for teachers and pupils. This space has many advantages over a standard classroom, resulting in an improved educational experience.

The design goal for this plaza was to accommodate 60-90 pupils, providing all aspects of teaching, focussing on both individual and group learning. The completed plaza provides a wide range of teaching spaces.

1 - Small group work tables have been dotted throughout the plaza. The carefully considered distance between desks helps reduce disruptive, unnecessary communication between group tables, resulting in reduced noise levels within this space.

2 – More private, cluster spaces have been added by stepping out the facade. These spaces are acoustically and visually screened from the main teaching area, thereby creating a more private learning area.

3 - One of these spaces contains a glass screen to further increase privacy, making it ideal for one-on-one work or nosier group activities.

4 - Desks have been placed adjacent to the facade. The desks provide individual learning stations with the benefit of restricted visibility to the remainder of the plaza. Students using these desks should enjoy improved concentration due to a reduced amount of distraction.

5 - A divider/screen added along the length of these tables helps to further reduce noise levels, by restricting the line of sight along the length of the work stations.

6 - A large central group table has been added with students all facing inwards. This minimises shouting and improves visual communication between students.

7 - To enhance speech intelligibility for dictatorial teaching, banana-like tiered seating has been used. Here, students and teacher sit extremely close to each other, improving speech intelligibility and reducing the need for the teacher to raise his/her voice. Three dictatorial spaces have been provided, one at each end of the plaza and one in the corner behind an acoustically screened space. These spaces have the advantage of being somewhat acoustically separated due to their location.

8 - Acoustic screens have been added in many inventive forms to these spaces such as the banana seating itself, glazed screens, bookshelves and other arrangements.

9 - Enclosed spaces have been provided for activities involving higher noise levels.

10 - The increased wall space created by the stepping out the facade, acoustic screens and other factors all assist in optimising the acoustic treatments to this space.

6.4 Distance - Dictatorial Teaching

Speech intelligibility and a good visual connection are essential requirements for dictatorial teaching. Most learning environments will require a space where instruction and information can be transmitted to a large number of students at one time. It is therefore essential to have at least one or two areas dedicated to this type of teaching.

In order to maximise speech intelligibility during this type of teaching, the distance over which the spoken voice is required to travel should be minimised. Based upon acoustic on-site tests, it is advised that the distance between the teacher and pupils be kept less than 4.5m; however this distance does depend on background noise levels and other acoustic effects within the open plan environment.

To meet this requirement, seating layouts and furniture should to be considered. Images 1 & 2 show two example layouts incorporating a semi-circular and rectangular seating layout. It is clear that the more effective layout is the semi circular design.

A considerable reduction in communication distance can be made by removing tables and chairs. Raked seating is also an effective method, not only reducing the distance b between the teacher and pupils, but also improving the line of sight which in turn helps with speech intelligibility. This seating layout can be achieved by raising the pupils by means of small steps, cutting steps into the ground or raising the seating in the form of a Greek amphitheatre.

6.5 The Banana

The banana seating 3 has been successfully implemented in two open plan spaces; however the design principles behind the banana have been used by teachers for many years in a wide range of locations.

One concern which has arisen with respect to the banana is student health and safety issues. The feedback we have received is that this is not an issue; however it is important to recognise that there are alternative designs, see options 4 & 5, which seem to be safer options. During the design stages of the banana, it has been found that it is important to provide pupils with sufficient leg room. The design of the second banana has deeper seating and angled backs to accommodate these requirements.

It has also been found that over time, the bananas get moved and joined together within the teaching space in order to address different sized groups. A method of interlocking the bananas and moving this seating would therefore be a useful design feature.

6.6 Layout - Unsupervised Group Work

Unsupervised group work, while an important element in learning, can also be one of the greatest sources of noise within a teaching space. As a result, this activity can be significantly detrimental to the acoustic performance of open plan design. The ideal solution is to provide individual areas for groups to work together. These spaces need to be laid out to promote group learning, but also to prevent casual and non-work related communication between group tables.

One of the worst table arrangements for group work is layout 1. This layout encourages non-educational interaction between tables, which not only loses the focus of the group (from an educational
point of view) but also significantly increases noise levels, as communication tends to take place over larger distances. Placing group work tables throughout the learning space focuses groups and results in reduced noise levels 2. However, a possible drawback is that teachers are required to move around tables more and may find it difficult to focus or address a larger group. Separating group tables is demonstrably one of the most important design requirements of open plan spaces.

6.7 Layouts - Individual Learning

Open plan designs must allow for individual learning spaces. The key objective is to provide work stations which encourage individual learning, whilst limiting unnecessary conversation and distractions between work stations. This can be achieved by reducing the visual connectivity between work stations, by means of screens and the orientation of desks. Screens can be added between work stations or on the tables themselves. Locating seating
along the length of facades, walls or in corners or rows, are good methods of promoting individual learning. Improvements can also be made by limiting the movement of seats and as such swivel seats and seats on casters are not recommended.

To visit the MACH Blog
Click here